Electric vs Hydraulic Injection Molding: Which Should You Buy?
A comprehensive comparison to help you choose the right technology for your application, budget, and operational requirements.
Quick Summary: When to Choose Each
Choose All-Electric When:
- Precision and repeatability are critical
- Clean room or medical manufacturing
- Energy costs are high in your region
- Fast cycle times are needed
- Tonnage is under 500 tons
Choose Hydraulic When:
- Budget is the primary constraint
- Large tonnage (>500 tons) is needed
- High injection pressure/force required
- Local service favors hydraulics
- Processing difficult materials
Detailed Comparison
| Category | All-Electric | Hydraulic |
|---|---|---|
| Energy Efficiency | Excellent 30-50% less energy than hydraulic. No idle power consumption. Only uses energy during active motion. | Good to Poor Conventional: High idle consumption. Servo-hydraulic: 20-30% better than conventional, but still trails electric. |
| Precision & Repeatability | Excellent Direct servo control provides exceptional position accuracy (±0.01mm). Ideal for tight tolerances and micro-molding. | Good Modern servo-hydraulics are quite precise. Conventional systems have more variation due to oil temperature effects. |
| Cycle Speed | Excellent Faster dry cycles due to quick acceleration. Simultaneous axis movements. 10-20% faster cycles typical. | Good Adequate for most applications. Accumulator systems can match electric speed for specific movements. |
| Initial Cost | Higher 30-50% more expensive than comparable hydraulic. Premium for the technology and servo motors. | Lower Most economical option, especially at larger tonnages. Servo-hydraulic splits the difference. |
| Maintenance Cost | Lower No hydraulic oil, filters, or seals to replace. Simpler maintenance. Higher parts cost when needed. | Moderate Regular oil, filter, and seal changes required. Lower parts cost but more frequent service needs. |
| Clean Room Suitability | Excellent No hydraulic oil contamination risk. Minimal particulate generation. Ideal for Class 7/8 clean rooms. | Challenging Oil mist and potential leaks complicate clean room use. Requires additional containment measures. |
| High-Tonnage Economics | Challenging Cost premium increases significantly above 500 tons. Electric motors for high forces are expensive. | Excellent Most economical choice for large tonnage (500+ tons). Hydraulic power scales efficiently. |
| Demanding Applications | Limited May struggle with very high injection pressures or forces needed for thick-wall, difficult materials. | Excellent Easily delivers high pressure and force for demanding applications. Robust for difficult materials. |
Recommendations by Application
Medical Device Manufacturing
All-ElectricClean room compatibility, precision, repeatability requirements make electric the standard choice.
High-Volume Packaging
Electric or Servo-HydraulicFast cycles and energy savings of electric pay off. Servo-hydraulic if budget is tight.
Automotive Interiors (Large Parts)
Servo-HydraulicLarge tonnage requirements favor hydraulics. Servo provides energy savings over conventional.
Technical/Precision Parts
All-ElectricTight tolerances and repeatability requirements suit electric's precision.
General Purpose/Mixed Production
Servo-HydraulicBest balance of capability, cost, and efficiency for varied applications.
Budget-Constrained Operation
HydraulicLower acquisition cost. Consider servo-hydraulic if energy costs are high.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are electric injection molding machines better than hydraulic?
Neither is universally 'better' - each has advantages. Electric machines excel in precision, energy efficiency, speed, and clean room applications. Hydraulic machines offer lower upfront costs, better high-tonnage economics, and superior performance for demanding applications requiring high injection pressure or clamping force.
How much energy do electric injection molding machines save?
All-electric machines typically use 30-50% less energy than conventional hydraulic machines, and 15-25% less than modern servo-hydraulic machines. The savings are most significant during idle and cooling cycles. Payback period depends on energy costs and utilization.
Are used electric injection molding machines a good value?
Used all-electric machines offer excellent value, typically priced 30-50% below new while retaining most benefits. Key inspection points include servo motor condition, ball screw wear, and encoder function. Premium brands like Sumitomo, Fanuc, and Nissei retain value well.
What is a hybrid or servo-hydraulic injection molding machine?
Hybrid/servo-hydraulic machines use servo motors to drive hydraulic pumps, combining hydraulic power with improved energy efficiency. They offer 20-30% energy savings over conventional hydraulics at lower cost than full electric, making them a popular middle-ground option.
Which injection molding machine type is best for medical molding?
All-electric machines are preferred for medical molding due to: no hydraulic oil contamination risk, cleaner operation suitable for clean rooms, superior precision and repeatability, and quieter operation. Most medical molders standardize on all-electric for Class 7/8 clean room work.
Ready to Find Your Machine?
Browse our current inventory of both electric and hydraulic injection molding machines, or contact our team for personalized recommendations.
